South Korea's Defense Ministry said Friday it would review US procedures for handling sensitive military information, after a retired US Army general contradicted the minister on the transfer of wartime operational control.
The ministry added that it would take appropriate measures, if necessary, through close consultations with Washington.
"The results of joint assessments of the conditions for the OPCON transfer are classified South Korea-US military information that requires the same protection measures as each country's military secrets," the ministry said in a statement Friday.
Seoul's statement came after former US Forces Korea commander Robert Abrams on Wednesday questioned Defense Minister Kang Shin-chul's assessment that South Korea had met all three conditions required for the transfer.
In an interview with local media, Abrams, who led the USFK from 2018-2021, said the information he had obtained during a visit to South Korea in September contradicted Kang's assessment.
"Based on the latest information I have, I do not believe that all three conditions have been met," Abrams said.
"I'm not sure where Minister Kang gets his information, but that's not the same information that I have received as recently as September when I visited the Republic of Korea," he added, referring to South Korea by its official name.
Abrams was succeeded by Gen. Paul LaCamera in July 2021, before Gen. Xavier Brunson took command in December 2024. The USFK commander concurrently heads the South Korea-US Combined Forces Command, which is responsible for the allies' combined defense operations and would exercise wartime operational control over designated forces, as well as the United Nations Command.
Kang told a National Assembly budget committee session on Nov. 12 that all three conditions for the OPCON transfer had been met. The Lee administration aims to complete the transfer before Lee's term ends in 2030.
But the apparent access of retired US military commanders to sensitive OPCON-related information was a point of concern to Rep. Jin Sung-joon of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea, who chairs the National Assembly's National Defense Committee.
"Under what authority are former USFK commanders being briefed on South Korean and US military secrets?" Jin wrote in a Facebook post Thursday.
He called on the ministry to identify who had provided the information, through what procedures and under what legal authority, while demanding that the results of the full operational capability assessment be formally reported to the National Assembly, if necessary behind closed doors.
The ministry said it had strictly complied with the requirements for protecting classified information.
The USFK did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
An official familiar with USFK procedures, however, said retired US military officers may retain their security clearance eligibility after leaving active service and may be granted access to classified information when properly authorized.
"Such access would not necessarily constitute a security violation, as long as the relevant authorization and security requirements are met," the official said.
Abrams was not the first former USFK commander to publicly challenge Seoul's assessment that the conditions for the transfer had already been met.
Earlier, on Nov. 13, another former USFK commander Vincent Brooks, who served from 2016-2018, also expressed disappointment at Kang's remarks during a discussion hosted by the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies.
Brooks questioned whether the transfer could proceed before the conditions agreed upon by Seoul and Washington had been met.
Regarding Kang's remarks at the National Assembly, the ministry explained Friday that the minister had intended to emphasize that South Korea and the US already possess comprehensive deterrence capabilities against North Korean threats and maintain a robust defense posture.
"Our military has developed much of the capabilities and infrastructure required for the OPCON transfer over the past two decades, while consultations between South Korea and the US are continuing over certain remaining capabilities," the ministry said.
flylikekite@heraldcorp.com


