Kakao founder Kim Beom-su arrives at the Seoul High Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on Friday for an appeals court ruling on charges of conspiring to manipulate SM Entertainment shares. (Yonhap)
Kakao founder Kim Beom-su arrives at the Seoul High Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on Friday for an appeals court ruling on charges of conspiring to manipulate SM Entertainment shares. (Yonhap)

The Seoul High Court on Friday upheld Kakao founder Kim Beom-su’s acquittal on charges of manipulating SM Entertainment shares during a takeover battle with Hybe, finding prosecutors had failed to prove an intent to rig prices.

The ruling was the second acquittal for Kim, who said the decision marked a turning point in three years of uncertainty surrounding Kakao.

Bae Jae-hyun, Kakao’s former chief investment officer, was also acquitted on appeal.

The case centered on Kakao’s purchases of SM shares in February 2023. Prosecutors alleged that Kim and other defendants conspired to keep the stock above Hybe’s tender offer price to thwart the rival bidder’s attempt to acquire the K-pop agency.

The appeals court said that purchases affecting a share price did not, by themselves, establish market manipulation.

“All transactions have the potential to affect market prices, albeit to varying degrees,” the court said. Punishing purchases solely because they may have influenced prices would unfairly expand the scope of criminal liability, it added.

The evidence did not establish that the defendants intended to artificially manipulate or stabilize prices, or that they conspired to do so, the court found.

The reasoning echoed the lower court’s finding that Kakao’s large purchases during Hybe’s tender offer period could not automatically be treated as stock manipulation, even if they moved SM’s share price.

Prosecutors had appealed the initial acquittal and sought a 15-year prison term and a 500 million won ($373,000) fine for Kim at the appeal’s closing hearing in September.

In a statement after the ruling, Kim thanked the court, Kakao employees and those who had continued to support the company.

He also called for sweeping changes as AI reshapes industries and daily life.

“Kakao, too, must open a new path for growth,” Kim said. “This is a time for structural and bold changes to lay the groundwork for a resurgence.”

He pledged to contribute to new initiatives and growth while taking a long-term view of Kakao’s future as its founder.


herim@heraldcorp.com