[Election 2022] Fan clubs and phone recordings, candidates’ wives in spotlight
Poll shows voters have high expectations for future first lady, experts warn of ‘lopsided voyeurism’
Published : Jan 20, 2022 - 16:55
Updated : Jan 20, 2022 - 18:00
The composite photo of Kim Keon-hee, the wife of Yoon Suk-yeol, the presidential candidate from the main opposition People Power Party. (Kim’s online fan club “Keon Love”)

As the presidential election is drawing near, an unexpected figure jumped into the spotlight: Kim Keon-hee, the wife of Yoon Suk-yeol, the candidate from the main opposition People Power Party.

After controversial recordings of her phone call with a reporter were published last weekend, Kim has gained an unusual fandom, with her online fan club witnessing its members grow exponentially in only a couple of days.

While the latest phenomenon reflects the high expectations the electorate holds for the country’s first lady, experts warn the excessive attention shows “lopsided voyeurism” that could hurt democracy in the long run.

Scandals, allegations and fan clubs

In presidential elections, public attention often follows the spouses of the presidential nominees, and parties are always ready to dig up dirt on rivals.

Since her husband was chosen as the main opposition party’s presidential candidate, Kim has been the subject of unchecked rumors. One such rumor is that she worked as a hostess at hotel nightclubs. In addition, allegations about her past have made headlines.

As a portion of recordings of Kim’s private phone call was made public by local broadcaster MBC on Sunday, her uncensored remarks -- those undermining the country’s #MeToo movement and showing support for a former governor serving jail time for sexual abuse -- immediately came under fire.

But some comments critical of both the conservative and liberal blocs, and showing the couple’s political inclinations were also perceived as “candid” and “refreshing,” overturning the expectation that the revelation would hurt Yoon’s reputation.

Her online fan club “Keon Love,” which was launched on Dec. 19, and had only about 200 members on Saturday, saw its membership grow rapidly in the past week after the recordings were publicized. As of Thursday afternoon, the fan club had over 39,000 members.

The front page of the fan club site shows a composite photo of Kim’s face on a Wonder Woman movie poster and links to a collection of social media posts idolizing her.

Her mysterious background and unique character also appear to have drawn people’s attention, Eom Gyeong-yeong, director of the Zeitgeist Institute, told The Korea Herald.

“Kim appears to have lived a life different from the society’s ‘normal’ standards. For example, her late marriage may have increased people’s curiosity,” Eom said. Kim and Yoon married in 2012, when Kim was in her early 40s and Yoon was in his 50s.

The private conversation that showed of her character also appears to have triggered public interest in Kim, who has been keeping a low profile despite calls for her to appear at campaign activities for Yoon.
Lee Seung-bae, husband of Justice Party presidential candidate Sim Sang-jeung appears on an entertainment program by SBS in December. The subtitle reads, "husband working at home." (Screencaptured from SBS YouTube channel)

Public vetting of spouses

The public attention is not only focused on Kim Keon-hee. Ruling party presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung’s wife Kim Hye-gyeong has also been in the limelight, since Lee was the governor of Gyeonggi Province.

Kim Hye-gyeong has faced public scrutiny for her past actions and attitude several times, most recently when her telephone conversation with Lee’s niece was leaked. Although the phone call was private family matter, her hostile demeanor and use of foul language came under fire.

Because most presidential candidates have been men, their wives have often been the subject of attention. But after Sim Sang-jeung, the presidential candidate of the progressive Justice Party, appeared on a reality show in December with her husband, he was also seen as being a “supportive husband.”

The physical appearances and attire of the spouses of candidate’s spouses are also a common point of interest during this election season. A local monthly publication recently interviewed “gwansang” experts, or face-reading prophets, to analyze the facial features of the spouses to describe their personalities, and to predict if they are born with the “luck and energy” to lead their husbands if they are elected as president.

“(The excessive attention to the spouses) appears to reflect the lopsided voyeurism rampant in society,” Eom said.

Eom warned that the scandals and rumors that have been raised are mostly private matters, and have come to distract important discussions on the candidates and their capabilities to handle state affairs.

“(Excessive attention on spouses) can lead to cynicism and satire in politics, and it could damage the cause of political parties and democracy in the long run.”

Kim Hye-gyeong (left), wife of Democratic presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung, and Kim Kun-hee, wife of the main opposition People Power Party’s candidate Yoon Seok-youl (Yonhap)

First lady, a figure at the heart of power

In presidential elections, the spouses of presidential candidates have always been the subject of interest for the public, as society holds high expectations for the person who will become the first lady.

The interest was clearly shown in polls. According to a survey by Research & Research commissioned by Channel A and conducted from Nov. 27 to 29, 55 percent of voters said their preference towards the spouses of the presidential candidates affect their choices, while 37.7 percent said it does not.

In another poll by KSOI commissioned by TBS, conducted from Dec. 17 to 18 to 1,008 adults, 68.3 percent said the scandals involving the spouses affect their choice of vote -- among them 40.9 percent said they have “much influence.” The survey showed that 29.3 percent of the voters were not affected by the spouses, while 2.4 percent said they do not know.

As much interest is concentrated on who will become the country’s next first lady, the position does not hold any legal duty to serve the country.

Still, a first lady stands in a powerful position and has the social influence to put a spotlight on issues the president misses out on. This is witnessed in the examples of past first ladies, Choi Jin, the head of the Institute for Presidential Leadership, told The Korea Herald.

“In Korea and also in the US, it is common to believe the spouses are second-in command. While it is not openly seen, they have an influence the president,” Choi said.

At the same time, the public is sensitive about outer force interfering in political state affairs, so the spouses often face rigorous vetting process by the people, he added.

A nation’s first lady is “the closest partner to the president at the heart of power,” Cho Eun-hee, who released several reports on the country’s first ladies, wrote in her book, “Korea’s First Ladies.”

“Korea’s First Ladies. They accompanied the country’s top commanders throughout Korea’s turbulent modern history, and they also received spotlight,” Cho said in the book.

“They played the role of connecting the president isolated on the peak of power to reality, delivering the public opinion. At the same time, they were prisoners behind the bar of people’s eyes.”

For more information regarding the survey results, visit the National Election Survey Deliberation Commission homepage.

By Jo He-rim (