Send to

[Yao Yunzhu] Thawing China-U.S. military relations

Jan. 21, 2011 - 19:56 By 류근하
The recent visit by U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates to Beijing has been widely interpreted as marking the restart of Sino-U.S. military ties, which were damaged by the Barack Obama administration’s decision to approve a $6.4 billion arms sale package to Taiwan in early 2010. 

Both sides described the visit as successful and positive and agreed to build stable military relations by taking gradual practical steps. The success of Gates’ visit has also helped to create a warm and constructive atmosphere for President Hu Jintao’s visit to the U.S. this week. After a turbulent year in Sino-U.S. military relations, things are beginning to look more sanguine.

Although analysts in China and the U.S. perceive the overall bilateral relationship as a process of ups and downs, in which recurring difficulties are either solved or shelved in pursuit of common interests, relations between the two militaries have lagged far behind and taken an on-and-off pattern, with the military relationship going through six on-and-off cycles in the last two decades.

The U.S. cut off all military ties as part of overall sanctions against China in 1989, both sides then suspended military exchanges because of rising tensions over Taiwan in 1995-96. China halted military exchanges after the U.S. bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade in 1999 and the U.S. severed military ties in the aftermath of the mid-air collision near Hainan Island in southern China in 2001. And China postponed and suspended military exchange programs in October 2009 and January 2010 in protest against proposed U..S arms sales to Taiwan.

This on-off pattern has reflected and also aggravated the lack of trust between the two militaries. The U.S. is wary of the economic and political influence of China and its growing military might, and the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA), still enduring continuous U.S. embargoes, sanctions, and calls for transparency, finds it hard to perceive its U.S. counterpart as a trustworthy friend.

In addition, as China’s most important core national interest, Taiwan is a constant issue for the two militaries. The 2005 Anti-Secession Law states that: “the State shall employ non-peaceful means and other necessary measures to protect China’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.” While the U.S.’ Taiwan Relations Act of 1979 states that, the U.S. “will make available to Taiwan such defense articles and defense services in such quantity as may be necessary.” The arms sales to Taiwan, even at the time when cross-Straits relations are improving, is the single most important factor jeopardizing Sino-U.S. military ties.

Furthermore, lack of meaningful military cooperation has reduced incentives for a lasting relationship. In the 1980s when military ties were closest, the then U.S. Secretary of Defense Caspar W. Weinberger suggested military relations be based on three pillars: high-level visits, functional-level exchanges and cooperation in military technology. Currently, with the U.S. still imposing sanctions against the Chinese military, placing legislative limits on military exchanges, and making alarmist voices about “China’s military threat” each and every time China shows progress in modernizing its military, it is difficult to sustain a robust relationship.

However, the attention attached to Gates’ visit has shown that military relations are an important part of the overall relationship. The U.S. and China have reached a consensus that relations should be “healthy and stable” (in the words of President Hu Jintao), or “solid, consistent and not subject to shifting political winds” (in the words of Secretary Gates). China and the U.S. share more and more common interests in dealing with contemporary global security issues. China and the U.S. also share greater stakes in managing the differences and disputes between them. As two major international players, China and the U.S. are obliged to cooperate in global security and military affairs. And their militaries have to work together in bilateral, multilateral, regional and even global settings. The two militaries should cooperate to avoid unexpected crisis and ensure win-win solutions to problems.

However, military cooperation has to be enhanced in a step-by-step and practical manner to create mutual trust. China has stressed the principles of respect, mutual trust and reciprocity in developing military ties. In accordance with these principles, the U.S. should make serious efforts to remove the three obstacles to improving mutual trust and better cooperation ― arms sales to Taiwan, air and maritime reconnaissance against China, and legislation obstructing military exchanges.

If China and the U.S. agree that sound military relations are important and desirable, there must be a clear chart of how to move relations forward, as the relationship is becoming too consequential to become mired in the past. 

By Yao Yunzhu

Yao Yunzhu is a major general and senior researcher at the Academy of Military Science of the PLA. ― Ed.

(China Daily/Asia News Network)